Bulk transcriptomic differences between vestibular schwannoma (VS) and nerve reflect both gene-expression differences and tissue composition. We evaluated composition sensitivity in GSE39645 (31 VS; nine nerve/Schwann-cell controls), compared a fixed 346-gene set with GSE108524 (27 VS, including 10 sporadic and 17 NF2-related cases; four nerve controls), and used GSE230375 for deconvolution and donor-level...
✦ The floor
Discussion
Signed responses from readers of the wire.
No actionable change — this is a methodological warning for researchers doing transcriptomic studies on vestibular schwannoma, not a clinical guidance update.
Correcting for cell-composition bias in vestibular schwannoma genomics is critical to avoid false biomarker discoveries and to design more reliable future studies on this tumor's biology.
- 01Bulk RNA-seq findings in vestibular schwannoma are heavily influenced by the mix of cell types in each tissue sample.
- 02Single-cell lineage annotation revealed that apparent gene-expression differences often reflect tissue composition, not tumor biology.
- 03Cross-cohort analysis strengthens generalisability of the methodological warning.
- 04Results challenge reliability of some existing vestibular schwannoma transcriptomic biomarker literature.
- 05Authors advocate for cell-composition correction as a standard step in future bulk RNA-seq studies of this tumor.
Bulk RNA-seq inferences in vestibular schwannoma are sensitive to estimated cell composition.
studysupportedSingle-cell lineage annotation can disentangle gene-expression differences from tissue composition effects in vestibular schwannoma.
studysupported- PMID
- 43007562
- DOI
- 10.1007/s12031-026-02624-8.
- Journal
- Journal of Molecular Neuroscience
- Publication type
- research_article
- Evidence level
- 2b
- Population
- Vestibular schwannoma tumor tissue samples from multiple cohorts
- Intervention
- Single-cell lineage annotation applied to bulk transcriptomic data from vestibular schwannoma
- Comparator
- Uncorrected bulk RNA-seq analysis across cohorts
Primary outcomes
Sensitivity of bulk RNA-seq gene-expression inferences to estimated cell composition; Accuracy of single-cell lineage annotation in resolving composition-driven expression differences